Basic structures of supervisory reporting largely in order – development needs in quality assurance
The Financial Supervisory Authority (FIN-FSA) has assessed the organisation of supervised entities’ supervisory reporting, related reporting processes, quality assurance and the management of changes to reporting requirements. In connection with the thematic review, questions were also asked more generally on themes related to supervisory reporting, such as the most relevant cost drivers and overlaps between different reports. The thematic review was carried out as a survey addressed to supervised entities. Approximately 50 supervised entities from the insurance, pension, capital markets and banking sectors responded. The findings of the thematic review are based on the responses and descriptions submitted by the supervised entities.
Key development needs identified in practices and operating methods:
- The basic structures and responsibilities of supervisory reporting were organised appropriately in main respects, but individual shortcomings were identified in the clarity of the division of responsibilities and in the segregation of production and control tasks.
- Processes for handling and correcting reporting errors were for the most part in place, but shortcomings were found in approval practices, in root-cause and impact analyses, and in the maintenance of correction and version history.
- The accuracy of reported data was based extensively on reconciliations, validations and various checks. Some responses left the actual effectiveness, automation and documentation of the controls unclear.
- Fragmented documentation of manual work stages hinders the traceability of data and the transparency of changes made.
- Deputy arrangements and the transparency of available resources varied. Particular attention should be paid to these when both reporting and related change management have been assigned to individual persons.
- Consistency between internal, supervisory and public reporting was generally at a good level, but systematic reconciliation, justification and documentation of differences between reports was a practice followed only by some of the respondents.
- The degree of adoption of the authority’s validation rules, quality-assurance controls implemented in systems, and additional checks in supervised entities’ own systems varied by sector. Some respondents had clear shortcomings in the implementation of automatic validations.
- Information on the quality of supervisory reporting is reported to management and/or the board of directors to varying degrees across sectors. The monitoring and reporting of indicators describing the quality of supervisory reporting does not appear to be an established practice in all sectors. Shortcomings in the monitoring of data quality and in management reporting weaken the ability to identify and manage risks related to data quality.
Practices and operating methods found good and advisable:
- Clearly described data ownership determines who is responsible for the accuracy of the data and prevents the fragmentation of responsibility.
- The inclusion of requirements concerning the adaptability and quality of ad hoc reporting in continuity and crisis-management plans, and regular testing of the functioning of deputy arrangements, supports supervised entities’ ability to produce high-quality and up-to-date information also in crisis situations.
- It is advisable to include the development of controls and the updating of work instructions in the error-correction process, so that similar errors can be prevented in future.
- It is advisable to reconcile and document the data used in internal and external reporting frameworks, so that the same information is reported consistently to different parties.
- The management of changes to reporting is based on responsibilities, processes and a governance model that are clear and documented.
- It is advisable to incorporate the authority’s validation rules into the supervised entity’s own systems and to supplement them with other quality-assurance controls suited to the content of the reporting.
- It is advisable to monitor data quality regularly with indicators that are also reported to management. The overall view reported to management and, where necessary, to the board of directors also includes identified quality shortcomings and corrective measures.
The FIN-FSA will take the findings of the thematic review into consideration in its ongoing supervision and will, where necessary, target follow-up enquiries based on the findings made. The FIN-FSA also expects supervised entities to assess their arrangements and processes for supervisory reporting against the findings and good practices presented in this release and in the thematic review report.
For further information, please contact
- Sinikka Taskinen, Senior Specialist, sinikka.taskinen(at)fiva.fi
- Arttu Kiviniemi, Head of Division, arttu.kiviniemi(at)fiva.fi
Appendix
Thematic review report (in Finnish)